Casey was working for Kandy Welding Co., a company that held ties to Jack's White Supremacist Gang. The day after the massacre at the White Supremacist Compound, Casey and his colleague Neil visit Todd Alquist's apartment while disguised as police officers in order to find the drug money that Todd had hidden there. However, they stumble upon Jesse Pinkman, who came there for the same reason. Jesse is then found by the two and deceived into giving himself up and is taken hostage. Shortly afterwards, Casey is forced to follow Lou, who was Todd's neighbor and believed he possessed evidence that could help the police.
After Jesse arrives at Kandy Welding Co. in order to get more money, Casey finds out that what he believed was a half of the cash hidden at Todd's house was only a third of it. As Jesse and Neil face off, Casey eyes his gun before Neil suggests an Wild West-style duel to determine who will get the money. Jesse kills Neil with a second gun hidden in his jacket and Casey begins shooting at him. Jesse returns fire with first his Colt Woodsman and then Neil's gun. Finally, Jesse's manages to shoot Casey in the head, sending Casey headfirst through the glass of a vending machine, killing him. After scaring off Neil and Casey's friends, Jesse blows up the building to cover up their deaths. ("")